P2P Between Mobiles
Peer-to-peer calls between mobile phones is something I’ve wanted to see for a long time. It makes sense being able to call or connect directly between two mobile devices from a basic technical point of view. Clearly this isn’t something the mobile operators would be too keen on though, allowing users to call freely between each other.
However, according to this BBC story a Swedish company TerraNet appears to have come up with a solution:
You can call and text anyone within two kilometres, or up to 20 kilometres in a mesh network. What’s more, you can call and text anyone in the world through a TerraNet wireless Internet access point. With TerraNet technology integrated any type of handheld device transforms into a wireless communicator.
The technology integrates seamlessly with wired and wireless VoIP solutions.
Sounds great, but sadly their site is lacking in proper technical details or even hardware pictures. Which leads me to suspect this may be over-hyped. There is also no mention of open standards which for me puts in the same ball park as Skype (which in comparison is very similar indeed.)
Mesh systems are impressive in theory, but I’ve yet to actually see one working, especially over wireless connections (maybe someone can correct me?). Adding complications to this is the fact that most people tend to be moving around when they are talking on their mobiles, and even more so when in standby in a pocket. This must make it especially difficult to maintain a decent channel between two users calling from one side of the mesh to the other. Perhaps these phones are meant to be static?
I remember when I spoke to Negroponte and asked about how the Mesh side of the OLPC project was going, he said that one of the main problems with a mesh network is deciding which route to take from the client to the server when there are a large number of users. I got the impression they were still working on the protocols to deal with this sort of thing to provide a reliable connection.
I don’t think the walky-talky market need worry too much yet, but I’d love to be wrong!
